TRANSPORTATION PROGRAMS: OPPORTUNITIES FOR OVERSIGHT AND IMPROVED USE OF TAXPAYER FUNDS. TESTIMONY
It is important to ensure that long-term spending on transportation programs meets the goals of increasing mobility and improving transportation safety. In this testimony, the General Accounting Office (GAO) discusses what recently completed work on four transportation programs suggests about challenges and strategies for improving the oversight and use of taxpayer funds. These four programs are (1) the federal-aid highway program, administered by the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA); (2) highway safety programs, administered by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA); (3) the New Starts program, administered by the Federal Transit Administration (FTA); and (4) the Essential Air Service (EAS) program, administered out of the Office of the Secretary of Transportation. The federal-aid highway program illustrates the challenge of ensuring that federal funds (nearly $30 billion annually) are spent efficiently when projects are managed by the states. GAO has raised concerns about cost growth on and FHWA's oversight of major highway and bridge projects. Recent proposals to strengthen FHWA's oversight are responsive to issues and options GAO has raised. Options identified in previous GAO work provide the Congress with opportunities to build on recent proposals by, among other things, clarifying uncertainties about FHWA's role and authority. NHTSA's highway safety programs illustrate the challenge of evaluating how well federally funded state programs are meeting their goals. Over 5 years, the Congress provided about $2 billion to the states for programs to reduce traffic fatalities, which numbered over 42,000 in 2002. GAO found that NHTSA was making limited use of oversight tools that could help states better implement their programs and recommended strategies for improving the tools' use that NHTSA has begun to implement. The administration recently proposed performance-based grants in this area. FTA's New Starts program illustrates the challenge of developing effective processes for evaluating grant proposals. Under the New Starts program, which provided about $10 billion in mass transit funding in the past 6 years, local transit agencies compete for project funds through grant proposals. FTA has developed a systematic process for evaluating these proposals. GAO believes that FTA has made substantial progress by implementing this process, but their work has raised some concerns, including the extent to which the process is able to adequately prioritize the projects. The Essential Air Service (EAS) program illustrates the challenge of considering modifications to statutorily defined programs in response to changing conditions. Under the EAS program, many small communities are guaranteed to continue receiving air service through subsidies to carriers. However, the program has faced increasing costs and decreasing average passenger levels. The Congress, the administration, and GAO have all proposed strategies to improve the program's efficiency by better targeting available resources.
- Record URL:
U.S. General Accounting Office441 G Street, NW
Washington, DC United States 20548
- Publication Date: 2003-7-22
- Pagination: 32 p.
- TRT Terms: Air transportation; Bridges; Costs; Evaluation; Federal aid highways; Federal government; Financing; Government funding; Grant aid; Highway safety; Highways; Oversight; Passengers; Project management; Public transit; Safety programs; Small cities; States; Strategic planning; Subsidies; Testimony; Transportation planning
- Identifier Terms: Essential Air Service program; New Starts Program; U.S. Federal Highway Administration; U.S. Federal Transit Administration; U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
- Subject Areas: Administration and Management; Aviation; Bridges and other structures; Finance; Highways; Passenger Transportation; Public Transportation; Safety and Human Factors; I10: Economics and Administration;
- Accession Number: 00960492
- Record Type: Publication
- Report/Paper Numbers: GAO-03-1040T, HS-043 563
- Files: HSL, TRIS
- Created Date: Jul 25 2004 12:00AM